In a load-bearing house, the walls themselves carry the roof and floor loads down to a continuous strip foundation. In an RCC framed house, the slab passes load to beams, beams to columns and columns to footings, while the brick walls only fill the gaps. In Nepal, both systems can be safe in earthquakes when built to the National Building Code: NBC 202 for load-bearing masonry, and NBC 205 or a full NBC 105 design for RCC frames. Most failures come from ignoring those rules, not from the choice of system.
Homeowners in Kathmandu, Pokhara or a village in Gorkha often ask which one to build. The answer depends on the number of storeys, plot size, budget, available skills and how much you want to change or extend the house later. This post explains how each system works, what the 2015 earthquake taught us and how they compare on cost and space.
How a load-bearing house carries load
A load-bearing structure uses brick, stone or block walls as the main vertical members. The roof slab or timber roof rests on the walls, the walls carry it to the ground, and a wide strip foundation spreads the load into the soil.
Because walls are both structure and partition, the plan has to be regular and walls must line up from floor to floor. You cannot remove a wall later to make a bigger room without affecting the structure.
For earthquake resistance, NBC 202 (the guideline for load-bearing masonry buildings) relies on a few simple but critical features:
- Horizontal RCC bands at plinth, sill, lintel and roof levels that tie all walls together like a belt.
- Vertical reinforcement at corners, wall junctions and beside large openings.
- Limits on openings, especially near corners, and on unsupported wall length between cross walls.
- Good mortar and bonding, with proper corner bonding and through-stones in stone masonry.
- Limits on the number of storeys and wall height.
Masonry in mud mortar is covered separately in NBC 203, which is aimed at low-strength masonry common in rural houses.
How an RCC framed house carries load
In a framed building, the reinforced concrete skeleton does the structural work. Slabs span between beams, beams frame into columns, and columns carry everything down to isolated or combined footings. Brick or block walls are infill. They add weight and some stiffness, but they are not meant to carry the floors.
For small, regular houses within its limits, NBC 205 gives ready-to-use sizes and detailing for low-rise RCC buildings, so a registered engineer can design and detail without full computer analysis. Buildings outside those limits need a proper structural design to NBC 105 (seismic design of buildings in Nepal). The details that matter most on site are:
- Adequate column size and bars. Current guidance discourages the old 9 inch x 9 inch (230 mm) column for houses; check NBC 205 for the minimum.
- Stirrups with 135° hooks and closer spacing near beam-column joints.
- Columns stronger than beams, so damage forms in beams rather than columns.
- No soft storey (an open ground floor with walls above), no short columns created by partial-height walls, and no columns sitting on beams.
Lessons from the 2015 Gorkha earthquake
The April 2015 earthquake and its aftershocks gave Nepal a hard lesson in both systems. In general terms:
- A very large share of collapsed houses in rural districts were stone or brick masonry in mud mortar with no bands, poor corner connections and heavy roofs. Walls separated at corners and fell outwards.
- Load-bearing houses built with seismic bands and corner reinforcement, as promoted by the building code and reconstruction programmes, generally performed much better.
- Many non-engineered RCC houses in towns were damaged because of slender columns, stirrups with 90° hooks that opened up, poor concrete, and soft ground storeys used as shops or parking.
- Well-designed and well-supervised RCC buildings mostly performed as intended.
The common thread is that the system matters less than whether the code details were followed and checked on site.
Worked example: how heavy are the walls
Take a 230 mm brick wall, 3 m high, with brick masonry weighing about 19 kN/m³.
Weight per metre length = 0.23 × 3 × 19 = 13.11 kN/m for one storey.
In a two-storey load-bearing house, the ground floor wall carries the upper wall too: 2 × 13.11 = 26.22 kN/m, before adding slab, roof, finishes and live load. This is why ground floor walls in load-bearing buildings are thick, and why the strip foundation runs under every wall.
In a framed house, that same 13.11 kN/m sits on a beam. The designer must know where walls go. Adding a new brick wall on a slab later, with no beam under it, is a common cause of cracking. The brick calculator helps you estimate brick and mortar for either system.
Load-bearing vs RCC framed: comparison
| Aspect | Load-bearing masonry | RCC framed |
|---|---|---|
| Load path | Slab or roof to walls to strip foundation | Slab to beams to columns to footings |
| Main code reference | NBC 202 (NBC 203 for mud mortar) | NBC 205 for low-rise; NBC 105 for full design |
| Typical use | One to two storey houses, rural and semi-urban areas | Urban houses, more storeys, shops below |
| Wall thickness | Thick, often 230 to 350 mm brick or thicker stone | Infill can be thinner where allowed |
| Layout freedom | Limited, walls must line up | Larger rooms and openings possible |
| Future extension | Difficult, limited by wall capacity | Possible only if designed for extra floors |
| Materials | More bricks or stone, less steel and cement | More steel and cement, formwork needed |
| Skill needed | Good masons, band and corner details | Good steel fixing, concreting and supervision |
| Earthquake behaviour | Good if banded and reinforced; poor without | Good if ductile detailing is followed; poor if not |
Cost and usable space
For a small one or two storey house, especially where bricks or stone are locally available, a banded load-bearing house is usually the cheaper option because it uses less steel, less cement and no column formwork. The trade-off is space. Thick walls take up floor area, and on a small plot of 3 to 4 aana in Kathmandu that loss is noticeable.
An RCC frame costs more per square foot in structure, but allows thinner walls, bigger openings, ground floor shops and planned future floors. Prices of steel, cement and labour change often, so compare both options with current local rates. The house construction cost estimator gives a starting figure, and the steel weight calculator helps check reinforcement quantities in the RCC option.
Which one should you build
- One or two storeys, regular plan, limited budget, good local masons: a load-bearing house to NBC 202 is a sound choice.
- Three or more storeys, shops below, small plot or plans to extend: an RCC frame designed by a registered engineer to NBC 205 or NBC 105.
- In either case, insist on proper supervision of the seismic details. They cost little and decide how the house behaves in the next earthquake.
Frequently asked questions
Can I add a floor on top of an old load-bearing house?
Only after an engineer checks the existing walls and foundation. Most older load-bearing houses were not designed for extra floors, and adding one increases earthquake risk.
Is a load-bearing house allowed in municipalities?
Many municipalities permit load-bearing houses within the limits of NBC 202, but rules on storeys and use vary. Check your municipality's building bylaws before design.
Are the brick walls in an RCC house useless for strength?
They are not designed to carry the floors, but they do add stiffness and weight. Removing or adding walls, especially on the ground floor, changes how the frame behaves in an earthquake, so consult an engineer first.
Comments
Post a Comment